The Male and Female Student-Athlete of the Year awards are presented annually to a ‘bona-fide’ male student-athlete and a female student-athlete of StFX University. The purpose of the awards shall be to encourage athletic and intellectual ability and to develop character and leadership among the student-athletes of StFX University.
| YEAR | SPORT | FEMALE AOTY | SPORT | MALE AOTY |
| 2023 | Hockey | Maggie Burbidge | Basketball | David Muenkat |
| 2022 | Rugby | Danielle Franada | Hockey | Liam Hawel |
| 2021 | n/a | (not awarded) | n/a | (not awarded) |
| 2020 | Hockey | Tyra Meropoulis | Soccer | Dan Hayfield |
| 2019 | Rugby | Joanna Alphonso | Football | Kaion Julien-Grant |
| 2018 | Hockey | Daley Oddy | Soccer | Dan Hayfield |
| X-Country | Angus Rawling | |||
| 2017 | Hockey | Sarah Bujold | Football | Tivon Cook |
| 2016 | Track & Field | Bridget Brennan | Hockey | Eric Locke |
| 2015 | Rugby | Emma Taylor | XC/Track | Scott Donald |
| 2014 | Hockey | Alexa Normore | Football | Ron Omara |
| 2013 | Rugby | Tyson Beukeboom | XC/Track | Connor McGuire |
| 2012 | Rugby | Tyson Beukeboom | Soccer | Michael Marousek |
| 2011 | Hockey | Suzanne Fenerty | Soccer | Michael Marousek |
| 2010 | Rugby | Ghislaine Landry | Basketball | Christian Upshaw |
| Volleyball | Catherine Thornton | |||
| 2009 | Rugby | Ghislaine Landry | Football | Steve Myddelton |
| Basketball | Christian Upshaw | |||
| 2008 | Rugby | Ghislaine Landry | X-Country | David Gerych |
| Hockey | Brayden Ferguson | |||
| 2007 | Rugby | Ghislaine Landry | Basketball | Neil MacDonald |
| Hockey | Stuart MacRae | |||
| 2006 | Soccer | Christa Barber | Basketball | Garry Gallimore |
| 2005 | XC/Track | Kim Hill | Hockey | Patrick Grandmaitre |
| 2004 | Rugby | Michelle Tremere | X-Country | Eric Gillis |
| 2003 | Rugby | Danielle Goulet | Football | Adam MacDonald |
| X-Country | Leanna MacLean | |||
| 2002 | Rugby | Danielle Goulet | X-Country | Eric Gillis |
| 2001 | X-Country | Lavinia Gough | Basketball | Randy Nohr |
| 2000 | X-Country | Lavinia Gough | Basketball | Fred Perry |
| 1999 | Soccer | Maria MacDougall | Hockey | Brad Peddle |
| 1998 | Basketball | Sarah Williams | Hockey | Shawn Silver |
| 1997 | Basketball | Theresa MacCuish | Football | Mark Farraway |
| 1996 | X-Country | Lisa Dunne | Football | Paul Frlan |
| 1995 | Basketball | Theresa MacCuish | Hockey | Dale McTavish |
| 1994 | Basketball | Theresa MacCuish | Soccer | Trevor Reddick |
| 1993 | Basketball | Theresa MacCuish | Basketball | Richard Bella |
| 1992 | Basketball | Donna Barton | Basketball | Danny McFarland |
| 1991 | Soccer | Julia O'Connell | Hockey | Allan MacIsaac |
| 1990 | Basketball | Sheila Murrin | Basketball | Wade Smith |
| 1989 | Basketball | Margie Murphy | Soccer | Glen MacDougall |
| 1988 | Field Hockey | Sue MacEachern | Hockey | Dave Purcell |
| 1987 | FHockey/BBall | Deanna Corbett | Hockey | Dave Purcell |
| 1986 | FHockey/BBall | Deanna Corbett | Hockey | Dave Purcell |
| Basketball | Kyle Gayle | |||
| 1985 | Basketball | Cathy Schick | Football | Don Dempsey |
| 1984 | Basketball | Marcelin McGinn | Basketball | John Hatch |
| Football | Don Dempsey | |||
| 1983 | FHockey/BBall | Adele Belliveau | Basketball | John Hatch |
| 1982 | FHockey/BBall | Linda Barcauskas | Basketball | John Hatch |
| 1981 | FHockey/BBall | Loraine MacCormick | Basketball | Varouj Gurunlian |
| 1980 | FHockey/BBall | Margaret Berthiaume | Football | Kevin Aver |
| 1979 | n/a | Marcia Fowler | Football | Jim Zien |
| 1978 | FHockey/BBall | Cindy Levangie | Hockey | Fred Cuvelier |
| 1977 | n/a | Joan Gillis | n/a | Peter MacKenzie |
| 1976 | Basketball | Helen Jensen | Football | Art Botyanski |
| 1975 | FHockey/BBall | Cindy Dean | n/a | Sean Pritchard |
| 1974 | Basketball | Helen Jensen | Soccer | Sean Riley |
| 1973 | FHockey/BBall | Kathy Fleiger | n/a | n/a |
| 1972 | FHockey/BBall | Diane Boulanger | n/a | n/a |